Dialectic Method & the Ring of Gyges
YOU WILL COMPLETE THIS TASK THREE TIMES FOR 3 DIFFERENT STUDENT IN THE SAME CLASS…SO MAKE ALL THREE PAPERS DIFFERENT AND USE COMPLETELY DIFFERENT REFERENCES
You will upload three one page word documents once complete
INSTRUCTIONS:
Choose one of the following topics and write a one-page response. You must use two sources and your paper must be done by MLA format.
Socrates developed the dialectic method as a way of pursuing a true understanding of some basic concepts of justice or ethics. How did he use the method? Does it, could it, work?
Plato advocates a theory of Forms as a way of establishing a foundation for making true claims about reality. What is that? Is it (or some variation) convincing?
The “Ring of Gyges” story is at the center of a debate over whether justice is the product of authority (or power) or whether there is some objective principle of justice. Examine this debate and take a side.
Plato explores what he takes to be the difference between knowledge and opinion. Examine his definitions and argument. Is it convincing? Plato’s “allegory of the cave” is meant to illustrate how we are supposed to know reality. How does the allegory work? What does it show? Is Plato’s theory of knowledge convincing?
