PIO in Today Environment Discussion

I’m studying for my Writing class and don’t understand how to answer this. Can you help me study?

Be kind, but thorough and critical (sense a theme?). Did the scholar answer the question that was assigned, succinctly and thoroughly? Did the paper deeply answer the Critical Analysis questions? Did it represent the majority of the universal intellectual standards? Was it well written and APA compliant? Did `it have a clear introduction (identified what it would discuss) and body with each main point supported by literature, and a closing that reiterated the main lesson.

In short, was it a well written analytical paper at the graduate student level?